Contract or Permanent? The B1 Recruitment Problem MROs Need to Address
If you speak to almost any MRO about recruitment, B1 Licensed Engineers will usually feature somewhere near the top of the list of difficult hires.
It's hardly surprising. Experienced B1s with the right licence, type ratings and recent aircraft experience are already in limited supply. But from what we see working in this market, the problem runs deeper than simply not having enough engineers.
The real challenge is that many of the B1s who are willing and able to move are not necessarily looking for the type of employment MROs want to offer. A significant proportion of the mobile workforce is made up of contractors who are accustomed to moving between projects, facilities and countries. Then there's the international B1 population, where engineers may be interested in permanent opportunities but require sponsorship to make the move possible.
When an MRO wants somebody permanent, already based locally, with unrestricted right to work, the correct type rating and recency, the available market becomes much smaller, and that's where the contractor versus permanent conversation becomes interesting.
The insight in this article is written by our Head of MRO Services
Aleck Mehra.

Why contractors remain such an important part of MRO
Contractors solve a very real operational problem.
Aircraft maintenance demand doesn't always arrive in a nice predictable pattern. Heavy checks come in, new programmes start, customers increase capacity and maintenance schedules change. An MRO can go from having sufficient manpower to needing additional licensed engineers relatively quickly. Building permanent headcount around every peak in workload would be expensive and, in some cases, unnecessary. Contractors give an MRO the ability to bring in experienced capability for the period it is actually needed.
They are also naturally more mobile. An established contractor is generally used to travelling for work and moving between facilities, which gives MROs access to a much wider talent pool than the number of engineers living within commuting distance of the hangar. But, of course, that flexibility comes at a price.
If an engineer is required consistently throughout the year, paying contractor rates indefinitely can become difficult to justify. There is also less certainty around retention because contractors can respond to the market. If another project offers a significantly better rate, roster or location, they have far fewer reasons to stay than a permanent employee. This doesn't make contractors expensive permanent employees, but it means MROs are partly paying a premium for flexibility.
So why not just hire those engineers permanently?
This is where the problem becomes more complicated.
An established contractor isn't necessarily sitting there waiting for the right permanent vacancy to appear. Many have deliberately chosen contracting. They may value the earning potential, but often it is also about having control over where they work, when they work and how much time they take away between projects. So when an MRO offers that person a permanent job, the comparison isn't really between one permanent salary and another, it's between the permanent package and the contractor's existing lifestyle.
This changes what a competitive offer looks like. Salary matters, obviously, but so might the shift pattern, overtime arrangements, travel, benefits, type training, progression and how regularly that person can be at home. A permanent package can be perfectly competitive against another permanent MRO and still do very little to tempt an established contractor.
This doesn't mean contractors can't be converted. Some reach a stage where travelling loses its appeal. Stability becomes more valuable, particularly when family circumstances change or an engineer wants to progress towards a supervisory, technical or management position.
The point is simply that going permanent has to solve a problem for the engineer as well as the MRO.
The value of a permanent workforce
There are good reasons MROs want permanent B1s. An engineer who stays within the organisation builds familiarity with its customers, procedures, people and operation, all of which has value beyond simply signing off aircraft.
Over time, those engineers can support less experienced mechanics, become supervisors and develop into the technical leadership of the business. It creates continuity that constantly changing contract manpower cannot completely replicate.
If an MRO knows it needs a particular B1 capability consistently for the next few years, developing that capability permanently makes sense.
The difficulty is finding enough people willing to take those positions, particularly when the MRO then places further restrictions around where those people can come from.
And probably the biggest example of that is sponsorship.

Sponsorship makes the available market significantly bigger
There's a large international aircraft maintenance workforce, and many experienced engineers are prepared to relocate for the right long term opportunity.
But sponsorship is still something some MROs either cannot provide or would prefer to avoid. It introduces additional cost and administration, while international recruitment can involve relocation, licensing, approvals and longer lead times before somebody becomes productive.
But there's an unavoidable trade off.
Every restriction added to a B1 search reduces the number of people who can realistically be hired. The requirement for a B1 engineer ends up looking more like this:
Start with the B1 population. Now find the engineers with the correct aircraft type and recent experience. Remove those who don't want to relocate. Remove those who don't like the roster or package. Remove the contractors who aren't interested in going permanent, and then remove the international engineers who require sponsorship.
What initially looked like a large international talent pool quickly becomes a very, very small group of people.
This is why I think there is an important distinction between claiming that there aren't any B1 engineers available and acknowledging that there aren't many B1 engineers available under the conditions that are currently being offered.
The vacancy is the same, but there recruitment problem is very different.
It probably shouldn't be contractors versus permanent engineers
This is why I don't think the answer is choosing one workforce model. For most MROs, the more sensible conversation is about where each model fits.
A strong permanent B1 population can form the backbone of the operation. These are the engineers who provide continuity, develop knowledge of the customers and operation, and can ultimately progress through the organisation.
Contractors can then provide flexibility around that core workforce. If a heavy maintenance programme suddenly needs another 10 experienced licensed engineers for six months, trying to permanently recruit all 10 might not make sense. Contractors allow the business to respond to that demand without carrying unnecessary headcount once the workload falls again.
International recruitment can provide another option, particularly where an MRO has permanent requirements that simply aren't being filled from the local workforce. Sponsorship requires investment, but so does carrying critical vacancies for months while repeatedly searching the same limited local market.
That's why workforce planning needs to start with the nature of the demand rather than a blanket preference for permanent or contract labour. If the need is genuinely long term, invest in permanent capability. If the requirement comes from a spike in workload, use the flexibility that contractors provide.
If your permanent vacancies remain open because the local talent pool has been exhausted, it may be time to seriously consider whether international recruitment and sponsorship make commercial sense.
Are we asking the wrong question?
There's no denying that there's a shortage of experienced B1 Licensed Engineers. But this shortage becomes even more pronounced when MROs are all competing for the same narrow section of the workforce.
So when a business struggles to hire, the question shouldn't be: Where are all the B1 engineers?
It should be: Which of these roles genuinely need to be permanent? Where would contractors make more sense? Are we prepared to sponsor internationally? Are we offering enough to make an experienced engineer want to move?
These questions won't create more licensed engineers, but they'll significantly change the number of engineers an MRO is realistically able to access.
And perhaps that's the bigger point. In such a candidate short market, successful B1 recruitment isn't only about finding qualified engineers, it's about building a workforce model that the engineers you want can actually join.
How we can help:
If securing high-calibre B1 engineers is critical to your project or organisation, our Head of MRO Services Aleck Mehra can guide you through the process, connect you with the best talent in the industry and help you map out your organisation's long‑term pipeline.
Email: aleck.mehra@meritustalent.com
Call: 07441 391 885















